Review #146

Title- This Poison Heart

Author- Kalynn Bayron

Series- The sequel “This Wicked Fate” comes out June 2022

Rating– 4.8/5

Genre- YA fantasy

POV- first person, past tense

Trope- “chosen one,” family secrets

Steam level- 0/5

Cover– gorgeous and representative of the genre

Comps– A mix between “The Nature of Witches” and “The Gilded Ones”


Briseis has a gift: with a single touch she can grow plants from tiny seeds to rich blooms.

When Briseis’s aunt dies and wills her a dilapidated estate in rural New York, Bri and her parents hope that surrounded by plants and flowers, she will finally learn to control her gift. But their new home is sinister in ways they never expected―it comes with a mysterious set of instructions, a walled garden filled with the deadliest botanicals in the world, and generations of secrets. There is more to Bri’s sudden inheritance than she could have imagined, and she is determined to uncover it.

First chapter-

Bri has unique powers involving plants. She can make them grow, touch poisonous ones, and they react to her mood. Her fears are losing control and accidentally hurting a fellow student at high school. Yet the toxic plants are calling to her like a siren and she’s too curious to stay away.

Best part- All the secret rooms and hidden keys

What I would change- sometimes the character’s were super hesitant, then super excited, seesawing back and forth too quickly

Setting- outside of Brooklyn

Prose- it was interesting reading “tryna” in narrative instead of “trying to.” I’d only seen that done in dialogue before

Character goals/motivations- She wants to learn about her family, about what is hidden on the estate, and make new friends that will accept her powers.

Theme- secrets will get you nowhere, family means everything, self-acceptance no matter who/what you are

Vivid sensory descriptions- yes, especially with the plants

Dialogue- hilarious and realistic. The loving sarcasm and side remarks are perfect

Diversity- Bri, the main character is Black, as well as her friend, Karter. Bri is also bisexual and both her moms are fully supportive

Ethics/morals- murder

Conflict/tension/obstacles- enough, but sometimes the plot in itself was a little confusing

Pacing- fast

Thoughts while reading-

Page 32- confused by which is her biological mother or if it’s neither

Page 37- got it- she was adopted

Page 51- oh her parents definitely know something about her powers that they aren’t telling her

Page 63- if her aunt just died, why is it so dusty? Does the power of plants run in her blood? Will she find answers? I absolutely loved the apothecary room. It’s a little bit of a pet peeve when someone can give all the answers yet chooses to “wait” just for the sake of it. There needs to be a reason for the wait. The stranger in the dark was excellent. Overall I’m getting mixed feelings of whether Bri is excited or hateful for being at the estate. 

Page 106- it really increases the tension that Mom and Mo disagree on a path forward.

Page 115- a young Trevante Rhodes? Yes please

Page 177- there is a recurring issue where the characters’ perception or feeling or response about a situation seems contradictory of itself. Karter acted like he wanted nothing to do with this, then a sentence later was super excited. It’s confusing

Halfway- I’m glad she’s making a friend and feeling more comfortable with her skills. Her parents are hilarious. I still feel as if the characters go back and forth too much on where their head is at. 

Page 203- I’m confused. It felt out of the blue that there was a missing persons. Why hadn’t it been brought up before? Is this common in this town? Is it related to Marie or the estate?

Page 230- more questions are being piled on but none of the early ones are being answered. It’s hard to keep track now of all the things I’m wondering

Ending- Page 370- okay, so there was a twist but still semi expected. I liked that the end set up for a sequel with high stakes and a ticking time clock. But the second book doesn’t come out until June! I feel as if there’s still a few questions unanswered/unclear but overall I loved this story.

Published by CassieSwindon

Fiction author

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: